S5.C + N5.C
Who pays for a modification, and what design rules require
A reasonable modification changes the premises, such as installing grab bars or a necessary ramp. Under the Fair Housing Act and PHRA, the person with a disability generally pays for a necessary reasonable modification to existing premises. Where reasonable in a rental, restoration of the interior may be required, excluding ordinary wear and tear. Do not assume every useful change must later be removed.
Different obligations can apply to federally assisted housing under section 504 and to other accessibility laws. The tenant-pays rule doesn’t make a tenant cover the cost of fixing a provider’s own accessibility violation.
The federal design-and-construction requirements apply to covered multifamily dwellings first occupied after March 13, 1991. Coverage includes all units in buildings with four or more units and an elevator, and ground-floor units in other buildings with four or more units. Features include accessible common areas and routes, usable doors, reachable controls, bathroom-wall reinforcement and usable kitchens and bathrooms.
Work the example
In a privately funded covered rental with no construction violation, a tenant offers to pay for necessary grab bars.
Is this a modification or an accommodation to a policy?
Show answer and reasoning
A physical modification.
The request changes the premises. Apply the reasonable-modification rule and any reasonable interior-restoration condition.
Modification: the tenant generally pays. Design rules: covered multifamily first occupied after March 13, 1991.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Human Relations Act, definitions, housing duties and enforcement
- Federal source42 U.S.C. § 3604, housing discrimination and disability duties
- Federal source24 CFR § 8.33, housing adjustments in federally assisted programs
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
S5.C + N5.C
Read animal requests in light of HUD’s 2026 guidance changes
A no-pets policy doesn’t settle a disability-related animal request. The federal accommodation regulation still gives the example of a blind applicant who needs a seeing-eye dog. Pennsylvania also protects specified guide and support animal use, handling and training, and requires reasonable disability accommodations. PHRC’s current housing-complaint page lists charging a fee for support animals as a discrimination example.
Federal guidance changed in 2026. HUD’s April 2026 Federal Register notice reports withdrawal of the 2013 and 2020 animal guidance, effective September 17, 2025. Its May 22, 2026 memorandum tells FHEO staff to find reasonable cause and recommend charges in animal-accommodation cases only for animals trained to provide disability-related assistance. The memo does not address section 504 or ADA processing.
That is federal enforcement guidance, not a repeal of the PHRA or the Fair Housing Act’s accommodation text. Do not present the withdrawn 2020 guidance as current, and do not conclude that every emotional-support request may now be rejected or charged a pet fee. Evaluate the state, federal and local duties and seek qualified guidance on a disputed request.
For the exam, distinguish an ordinary pet from a disability-related request, a Pennsylvania protection from HUD enforcement policy, and a current statute or regulation from withdrawn guidance. A purchased online certificate doesn’t decide whether the requested accommodation is necessary and reasonable.
Work the example
A Pennsylvania manager hears that HUD withdrew old animal guidance and decides to reject every guide- and support-animal request without review.
What is wrong with that policy?
Show answer and reasoning
The guidance change did not erase Pennsylvania protections or the accommodation duty.
A categorical refusal ignores the particular animal, disability-related need and Pennsylvania law. The continuing trained-guide-dog example is especially clear.
HUD withdrew its 2013 and 2020 animal guidance; the PHRA and FHA accommodation duties remain.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Human Relations Act, definitions, housing duties and enforcement
- Pennsylvania authorityPHRC, housing complaints, examples and procedure
- Federal source24 CFR § 100.204, reasonable accommodations
- Federal rulemaking documentHUD, April 2026 notice of guidance withdrawals effective September 17, 2025Read the document's status and effective date; a proposed rule is not a final rule.
- Federal guidance copyHUD, May 22, 2026 animal-enforcement memorandum (copy hosted by DREDF)HUD guidance reproduced by DREDF. The source label identifies the memo and date.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.