S5.B
Why a land sale needs a signed writing
Pennsylvania’s Statute of Frauds generally requires a signed writing for an enforceable contract to transfer an interest in land. Identify the property, parties and agreed terms, and look for the signature of the party against whom enforcement is sought. An agent signing under the statute needs written authority.
Do not translate this into “every oral discussion is void.” Formation, proof and enforceability are different questions, and courts recognize fact-specific issues and exceptions. On the exam, a casual oral promise to sell land is not a substitute for the required writing.
Void means no legal effect from the start. Voidable means a protected party can choose to avoid the agreement. Unenforceable means a legal barrier prevents enforcement. Those words are not interchangeable. Refer an actual disputed oral agreement or unclear signing authority for legal advice.
Work the example
An owner orally agrees to sell a vacant parcel. The buyer asks the salesperson whether that conversation is enough to force the transfer.
What should the salesperson recognize?
Show answer and reasoning
The signed-writing requirement and the need for legal advice on enforceability.
The salesperson should not promise that the buyer can enforce an oral land-sale bargain or declare every possible exception resolved.
For a land sale, check the writing and authority as well as agreement.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authorityPennsylvania Statute of Frauds, land interests and written authority
- Pennsylvania authorityPA Superior Court, Rice Drilling B LLC v. Scott (2024), contract formation
- Pennsylvania authority49 Pa. Code § 35.292, Duties to all consumers
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
S5.B
Know when the brokerage agreement must be written
Under section 35.281, an agreement that commits a consumer to pay a broker a fee normally must be in writing and signed by the consumer. It must include the required service-agreement information. A broker can perform services before signing, but cannot recover a fee without the required signed agreement.
The regulation permits an oral open listing or oral nonexclusive buyer agency agreement if the broker gives the consumer a written memorandum stating the terms. This is a narrow state-law exception. It does not mean an exclusive listing may be oral, and it doesn’t override an MLS written-buyer-agreement policy that also applies.
Cooperating subagents and cooperating transaction licensees don’t need their own seller or landlord agreement. A subagent or transaction licensee working with a buyer or tenant while paid by someone else must give a written disclosure. The agency lesson covers those relationships and the disclosure details.
Work the example
A broker and buyer make a nonexclusive buyer agency agreement orally. The broker sends no written memorandum.
Has the broker met the exception?
Show answer and reasoning
No. The written memorandum is part of the exception.
Calling the arrangement nonexclusive does not make its required written terms disappear. Then check any MLS policy that applies.
Read exceptions with their conditions attached.
Sources and full lesson context
- Pennsylvania authority49 Pa. Code § 35.281, Written service agreements
- Pennsylvania authorityRELRA chapter 6, agency, compensation and disclosures
- Industry policyNAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101 (MLS policy)NAR or MLS policy. Check which participants and listings it covers.
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.