N3.B
When a lender needs an appraisal
A federally related transaction has a defined regulatory meaning. It doesn’t cover every mortgage. The banking rule, loan program, exemptions, state law and lender requirements together decide what valuation is needed and who may perform it.
For example, the FDIC rule in 12 CFR 323.3 provides threshold exemptions for qualifying residential transactions of $400,000 or less and commercial transactions of $500,000 or less. Below those thresholds the institution must still obtain an appropriate evaluation. Loan programs and investors often require an appraisal anyway.
An evaluation, an automated valuation model and an appraisal are not interchangeable labels. An AVM estimates value using a model and data; how useful it is depends on that data and the permitted use. A lender’s appraisal waiver does not turn an online estimate into a licensed appraiser’s report. Read what the program actually allows.
Work the example
An FDIC-regulated institution uses the residential $400,000 threshold exemption for a qualifying $350,000 transaction.
Does the exemption also remove the evaluation requirement?
Show answer and reasoning
No. An appropriate evaluation is still required.
The exemption removes the appraisal requirement but requires a collateral evaluation in its place.
FDIC thresholds: $400,000 residential, $500,000 commercial. Below them, an evaluation is still required.
Sources and full lesson context
- Federal source12 CFR Part 323, appraisal definitions, requirements and exemptions
- Federal sourceCFPB, different valuation methods during a mortgage application
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.
N3.B
Correct evidence without pressuring the value
An appraiser must develop an independent, impartial result. For covered consumer credit secured by a principal dwelling, Regulation Z prohibits coercing or otherwise improperly influencing the appraiser. Threatening to withhold future work unless the report reaches the contract price is not a legitimate review.
The rule allows requests to consider appropriate additional property information, explain a conclusion or correct errors. Send a documented factual concern through the lender’s review or reconsideration process. A missing comparable sale or incorrect room count calls for analysis, not an instruction to add a desired amount.
Value must not be based on unlawful discrimination. Use physical, legal and economic factors, never stereotypes about residents. A reconsideration request may or may not change the value, and shopping for a second report because it’s higher defeats real review.
Work the example
An agent supplies a relevant closed sale and asks the lender to have the appraiser review whether it affects the analysis. No target value or threat is given.
Is that the same as demanding a higher appraisal?
Show answer and reasoning
No. It is a request to consider relevant information.
Legitimate review addresses evidence and errors while preserving independent judgment.
Challenge the evidence with evidence, not a target price.
Sources and full lesson context
- Federal sourceCFPB, Regulation Z § 1026.42: valuation independence and permitted review
- Professional standardsThe Appraisal Foundation, current USPAP standards and guidance publications
- Federal source42 U.S.C. § 3605, financing and residential real estate transactions
Last reviewed November 15, 2026.